Analysis Problem of the Day 97

Today’s problem appeared as Problem 6 on the Texas A&M August 2021 Analysis Qual:

Problem 6. Show that if X is a separable Banach space, then there exists a bounded injective linear map from X into l^{2021}.


Solution: Note that with every Banach space we have the canonical embedding into the double dual i: X \hookrightarrow X^{**}. Moreover, since X is separable, the unit ball in X^* is weak-* metrizable, and by Banach-Alaouglu it is weak-* compact. Therefore, the unit ball in X^* is weak-* separable, i.e. there exists a countable subset \{\phi_n\} of functionals dense in the unit ball in the weak-* topology. More precisely, this implies that if \phi \in X^*, \|\phi\| \leq 1, then there exist a subsequence \phi_{n_k} such that \Psi(\phi_{n_k}) \to \Psi(\phi) for all \Psi \in X^{**} (this follows from the fact that sequences define the weak-* topology, since it is metrizable on bounded sets). Finally, let \{a_n\} \geq 0, a_n \not =0 for all n, be a sequence such that \{a_n\} \in l^{2021}. I claim that T: X \to l^{2021} given by Tx = (\phi_n(x)a_n) is the desired map. It is clearly linear, and since \|\phi_n\| \leq 1, \|Tx\|_{2021} \leq \|(a_n)\|_{2021}\|x\|. Finally, to show injectivity, by linearity it suffices to show that the kernel is trivial. Indeed, suppose that \phi_n(x)=0 for all n for some x \in X. Then, letting \widehat{x}=i(x), we note that \widehat{x}(\phi_n)=0 for all n. But by the weak-* density of \{\phi_n\} in the unit ball of X^*, we conclude that \widehat{x}(\phi) =0 for all \phi \in X^*, \|\phi\| \leq 1. By the Hahn-Banach theorem (which implies the existence of nonzero linear functionals) and the injectivity of the canonical embedding into the double dual, this implies that x=0, so T is an injective linear bounded map from X into l^{2021}, as desired.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *